On July 4, 1791, Absalom Stinchcomb received 200 acres on the North Fork of Dove's Creek, in what would become Elbert County. Just three years later, on December 30, 1794, Middleton Wood granted Stinchcomb, John Gatewood, and John Ham the privilege to build a meeting house on his land. Church tradition holds that Stinchcomb United Methodist Church began as a brush arbor meeting about a mile outside Dewy Rose, Georgia. While no legal record confirms the 1794 founding date, newspaper accounts in 1894 and 1984 marked its 100th and 190th anniversaries.

The present building, the oldest in Elbert County, was completed in 1876. A 1956 Georgia Historical Commission description praised its craftsmanship, noting hand-hewn timber sills measuring 14 inches square, logs used as joists, and a recessed porch where women once sheltered after dismounting from horseback. The structure remains in good condition and is an important architectural landmark for the community. The church cemetery reflects more than two centuries of local history. Veterans from the Revolutionary War, Civil War, World War II, and the Korean War are buried here, including Revolutionary War soldiers Dionysius Oliver and his son Peter, whose graves lie near the entrance.

During the first half of the 20th century, the congregation grew and made improvements to the building, adding gas heating in the 1950s and central heat and air in the 1970s. Through these changes, one tradition has remained constant. Since July 1939, members have contributed to the “Birthday Box,” a miniature replica of the church built by John W. Roberts. Each Sunday, birthday celebrants place their offering in the box as the congregation sings a hymn, followed by “Happy Birthday.” Blending history, tradition, and a strong sense of community, Stinchcomb United Methodist stands as both a place of worship and a living link to Georgia’s rural heritage.